Around 2 a.m., with the whole house asleep, the hall bathroom toilet hisses for a few seconds and then stops. Twenty minutes later it does it again. On other days the trouble is louder: someone flushes, and the water is still trickling ten minutes later until a jiggle of the handle shuts it off. When a toilet keeps running, the pattern of the running matters, because a tank only has four or five moving parts and each one fails in its own recognizable way.
Take the tank lid off, lay it on a towel where nobody will step on it, and watch a full flush.
What Happens Inside the Tank During One Flush
Three parts do the work. At the bottom center sits the flush valve, a round opening covered by a rubber flapper on a hinge, with a chain running up to the handle arm. Rising from the flush valve is the overflow tube, an open pipe that dumps excess water into the bowl so the tank can never spill onto the floor. Off to one side stands the fill valve, a tall assembly with a float on it, fed by the supply line underneath.
Press the handle and the chain lifts the flapper. The tank empties into the bowl in a few seconds, the flapper swings back down onto its seat, and the fill valve opens to refill. As the water climbs, the float rises with it until it reaches its set height and closes the valve. In a tank that is working properly, the water stops about an inch below the top of the overflow tube. Many tanks have a fill line molded into the back wall or printed on the tube.
Water Spilling Into the Overflow Tube Points to the Fill Valve
Watch the top of the overflow tube once the tank is full. Water steadily pouring into it means the fill valve never got the signal to close. This is the nonstop kind of running, the kind that goes all day.
The float is the first suspect. Most newer fill valves use a cup-shaped float that slides on the valve body, with a clip or a long adjustment screw that sets its height. Lower it until the water shuts off below the rim of the tube. Older toilets use a ball on a metal or plastic arm, and bending that arm gently downward has the same effect. Check, too, that the float moves freely and is not rubbing the tank wall or tangled in the flapper chain.
A float set at the right height that still lets water run over the tube means the valve’s internal seal is worn or has grit stuck in it. Well water is hard on fill valves for exactly this reason, since sediment and scale keep the seal from closing tight. Replacing the whole fill valve is the usual answer, and most replacements adjust to fit standard tanks.
A Toilet That Refills Itself Is Losing Water Past the Flapper
A toilet running intermittently, waking up for a few seconds with nobody near it, is often called a phantom flush. Nothing mysterious is going on. Water is seeping from the tank into the bowl, the level drops a little, the float sinks, and the fill valve opens to top it back up.
The EPA’s dye test confirms it in ten minutes: add a few drops of food coloring to the tank, do not flush, and look at the bowl once the time is up. Color in the bowl means the tank is leaking. Flush when you are done so the dye does not stain the porcelain (EPA WaterSense).
Flappers are rubber, and rubber ages. Over the years it hardens, warps and stops landing evenly on its seat, while mineral crust builds up on the seat itself. A toilet flapper replacement is one of the most manageable repairs in a house:
- Close the supply valve behind the toilet and flush to drain the tank.
- Unhook the old flapper from the two pegs on the overflow tube and unclip the chain from the handle arm.
- Run a fingertip around the flush valve seat. Rough or crusty spots should be cleaned off with a nonabrasive scrub pad.
- Bring the old flapper to the store. Flush valve openings are commonly 2 inches or 3 inches across, and a flapper in the wrong size will never seal.
- Attach the new flapper and chain, open the supply valve and repeat the dye test.
Chain Length Can Keep a Good Flapper From Closing
A brand new flapper will still leak if the chain is set wrong. Pulled too tight, the chain holds the flapper a hair above its seat, and water slips through nonstop. Left too long, the extra links can drift under the flapper and get pinched in the seal.
Aim for about half an inch of slack with the flapper closed. Cut off surplus chain instead of letting it dangle. A handle that stays down after a flush will also hold the flapper open, so a sticky or loose handle should be tightened or replaced at the same time.
A Faint Hiss Without Overflow Comes From the Fill Valve
Sometimes there is no water spilling into the tube at all, only a thin, steady hiss. That is typically a fill valve that is nearly closed but not completely. Pressure swings in the house can cause the same thing, since fill valves are built to work within a normal pressure range. A shower that runs weak, or faucets that seem stronger at some times of day than others, suggest the toilet is only one symptom, and our guide to low water pressure in the house explains how to check the rest of the system.
What a Running Toilet Does to a Well Pump and Septic Tank
Running toilets get ignored because they are easy to live with. The EPA warns that a worn flapper can leak thousands of gallons a year, and that fixing easily corrected household leaks can save homeowners about 10 percent on their water bills (EPA WaterSense).
Homes on a private well pay a different way. Every phantom refill starts the well pump, so a pump that should rest for hours ends up cycling all night. Septic systems take a hit as well: the EPA notes that a single leaky or running toilet can send as much as 200 gallons of water a day into the tank (EPA).
To find out whether this toilet is your only leak, close the supply valve behind every toilet and take a water meter reading while nothing in the house is running. A dial that keeps moving with the toilets isolated means water is escaping somewhere else, and professional leak detection can locate it without cutting into drywall on a hunch.
Pick a time to book Chesco Plumbing on our online calendar once the hiss has outlasted a new flapper, a shorter chain and a lowered float. By then the fault tends to be one that hides well, such as a hairline crack in the overflow tube, a pitted flush valve seat or a shutoff valve that no longer seals.
Problems That Need the Tank Off the Bowl
Adjusting a float, shortening a chain, replacing a flapper and swapping a fill valve are reasonable DIY jobs with the water off and a towel on the floor. A few faults are a different scale of repair:
- a shutoff valve behind the toilet that will not close, or drips from the stem after you turn it
- a crack in the overflow tube below the water line, which means replacing the flush valve with the tank removed
- water on the floor while you work, which can mean the tank to bowl gasket or tank bolts are leaking
- tank bolts rusted solid, common in older homes with hard water
A cracked overflow tube is easy to mistake for a bad flapper. The toilet sounds the same, and dye can still reach the bowl with a perfect seal because the water is draining through the crack. Before buying parts, run a flashlight slowly up and down the tube.
Ten Minutes With the Lid Off
A float set too high, a chain at the wrong length and a flapper that has stiffened with age account for most running toilets. One watched flush and a dye test will normally show which one you have, and a tank that still runs after those fixes has a deeper fault.
Some people would rather not spend a Saturday morning with an arm in a toilet tank, and that is a perfectly good reason to call Chesco Plumbing. Our licensed plumbers handle tank repairs, valve replacements and fixture work through our bathroom plumbing and plumbing repair services, and you can book a toilet repair online whenever you have a minute.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a running toilet an emergency?
Rarely. It wastes water but does no damage while the overflow tube is doing its job. The exception is a bowl that is rising toward the rim: turn the oval supply valve behind the toilet clockwise until it stops and leave it off until the cause is found.
Can I turn off the water to the toilet until I can fix it?
Yes. Close the supply valve and flush once, and the tank will stay empty. The toilet still works if you pour a pail of water straight into the bowl. Valves that have not been turned in years sometimes start dripping at the stem afterward, so look for a drip once it is closed.
Why does my new flapper still leak?
Three things cause most of these: a flapper sized for the wrong flush valve opening, a chain that is too tight, or a pitted seat that no rubber can seal against. Check that the flapper is hooked evenly on both pegs so it drops straight instead of landing crooked.
Should I replace the whole fill valve or just the seal?
Some fill valves have a replaceable cap seal that fixes a slow shutoff, which is a good option on a newer valve. A valve crusted with scale from well water, or one that is many years old, is usually better replaced as a complete assembly, which takes about the same effort.
How often should I check the inside of the tank?
Once or twice a year is plenty for most homes. Look at the flapper, the chain and the water level, and run a dye test while the lid is off. That catches a slow seep long before it shows up as a higher bill or a well pump that seems to run more than it used to.